Known as the most colorful prom dress collection on Cape Cod, our dresses are absolutely outstanding in the overall selection of colors, sizes and styles!  Last season, we had over 400 formals and we sold nearly ALL of them! Girls and women came from as far as Rhode Island and New Hampshire to get first dibs on favorite labels like Tony Bowles, Faviana, Sherri Hill, Cache and Jovani.


Our criteria for accepting prom dresses on consignment is "it's got to be trendy", and last season's styles did not disappoint our shoppers who were looking for the latest styles like 2pcs, high necklines, illusion lace and the most wanted colors of nude and blush.


Prom dress shopping in 2018 will be even more exciting, because our collection grows every year. We anticipate at least 400-450 prom dresses and other formals, with incoming new arrivals every day starting January 4 through March 31.


WHEN CAN I BRING MY DRESSES TO SELL? Ideally, the best time to bring dresses is Monday-Weds 10-5 and Thurs-Fri 10-2. If you bring dresses on the weekends, they will need to be dropped-off for later evaluation, which could take up to a week for us to get back to you. We much prefer to evaluate your dresses same-day, on the weekday times we noted above.


HOW CAN WE HELP YOU? Wicked Thrift is an incredibly supportive and happy store, carrying sizes that range from sz00 - super curvy (aka plus sizes). We always tell the truth about how a dress fits and encourage all of our shoppers to try on as many dresses as they can! It's not about the size, it's about the fit. So, come with an open mind. Prom dress shopping can be frustrating, but we're here to help you find a dress that makes YOU feel beautiful!


HAVE A DRESS TO SELL? Bring it to our Wicked Thrift in West Yarmouth anytime during store hours Jan 8 - March 31. We will help you sell it, then split it 50/50.


PRICE RANGES: We will push as hard as we can on values for consignors, while at the same time being absolutely realistic about what girls will pay for a used dress. Remember, everyone "only wore it once". Designer and premium labels gowns will have more value than mainstream store labels from places like Macy's and widely purchased obscure online labels. At the end of the day, what would you pay for someone's USED Sherri Hill dress?


WOMEN'S FORMALS - We sold over 125 womens formals in 2017! Our collection includes age-appropriate gowns that are perfect for all types of formal events, including military balls, destination weddings, bridal parties and Figawi.



Voted the best prom dress shop by class of 2016 & 2017